Saying a video is staged, without killing the joke
Three different duties get rolled into one word, disclosure, and only one of them is about staging. Which is which, and five places to put the label where it does not cost you the bit.
Published:
There are three duties, not one. Advertising disclosure applies when a post is paid for, whether or not anything is staged. Synthetic media labels apply when content could be mistaken for a record of real events. Plain honesty is nobody's rule and the one that keeps a post up: a viewer who feels tricked reports you.
Three duties, pulled apart
Advertising disclosure
If somebody paid for the post, or gave you the thing in the post, say so. This duty has nothing to do with props: a completely truthful video of a completely real product needs it. It is also the one that is actually enforced, by regulators, with names and numbers.
Synthetic and manipulated media labels
Platforms have their own category for content that could be mistaken for a real record of events, and several now ask creators to mark it. A prop wallet in an obvious comedy sketch is usually not the target of these rules; a staged screen in a video that presents itself as a document is closer to it. The rules are the platform's to interpret and they move, so the only durable advice is to check the one you post on rather than to reason from first principles.
Plain honesty
Nobody enforces this one and it is the one that matters. A viewer who works out that they were taken in does not file a complaint about synthetic media; they report the post and stop watching. The label is cheap insurance against your own audience.
The test that settles most cases. Would a reasonable viewer, having watched the whole thing, believe the money was real? If yes, label it. If the premise is obviously absurd, you have already labelled it by making it absurd.
Five places to put it, best first
- The first line of the caption. Seen by people who never reach the end of the video, which is most of them.
- The platform's own label. Costs nothing, satisfies the platform's rule by construction, and survives a repost.
- On screen, in the first seconds. Four words in a corner is enough. It reads as production rather than apology.
- In the premise. The strongest form: a bit that could not possibly be real needs no sticker. Comedy has done this for a century.
- In the end card. Better than nothing, worse than everything above it, because the people who needed it have gone.
What not to do
- A pinned comment. It is a disclosure addressed to people who already liked the video.
- Burying it in a hashtag wall. A tag among thirty tags is not a statement, and treating it as one is a decision to be technically covered rather than understood.
- Relying on a watermark that is not there. Larp Cards puts no mark on your cards and offers no label setting: what the site does is state plainly what the app is and is not. Saying a video is staged is the creator's call, and the tool will not make it for you.
Where disclosure stops being the question
All of the above assumes honest work. It stops applying the moment a screen is aimed at one person who has to decide something: a landlord, a lender, a buyer, an employer. There is no label that makes that acceptable, and it is forbidden by the terms here along with fake proof of funds, fake receipts and fake transfers. Where that line runs is a separate and shorter subject.
Questions
Do I have to say a skit is fake?
No rule requires a label on obvious fiction, and a skit that announces itself as a skit is already disclosed. The question only becomes real when the footage could be taken for a record of something that happened.
Where should the disclosure go?
Wherever it will be seen by someone who did not watch to the end: the caption's first line, an on screen line in the first seconds, or the platform's own label. A note in a pinned comment reaches almost nobody.
Does a disclosure protect me if the video deceives someone?
Not if the deception was the point. A label on a video made to obtain money from a specific person does not change what was done. Disclosure is for honest work, not cover for dishonest work.
Is an ad disclosure the same as saying it is staged?
No, and confusing them is the most common mistake. One is about who paid; the other is about what is real. A paid post with an unpaid prop needs the first and not necessarily the second.
Written by Larp Cards, a wallet app simulator: the cards are drawn from what you type, and nothing in it can pay. See the wallet.
Keep reading
- Guide: Where a prop wallet stops being a propThe uses the law addresses, the platform rules that are not the law, and the wide field both leave alone.
- Card finishes, and which ones survive a phone cameraMatte beats mirror, brushed beats polished, and holographic only exists if the card moves. What a lens does to a card…
- Why a fake wallet screenshot stops working on cameraA screenshot survives a scroll on a feed and dies the moment a camera watches it. The four moments that give one away, and…
- Four reasons a screen recording reads as a screen recordingA capture is mechanically different from a filmed shot in four ways, and all four survive colour grading. Which is why the…