Card finishes, and which ones survive a phone camera
Matte beats mirror, brushed beats polished, and holographic only exists if the card moves. What a lens does to a card surface, finish by finish.
Published:
A camera reads a card as a surface, and a surface is only visible as a gradient. Finishes that carry a gradient across them (matte, brushed, titanium, frosted) survive almost any light; finishes that return the room (gloss, mirror) or that need movement to exist (holographic, pearl) collapse in a static shot.
Why a finish is a lighting question
In your hand a card is lit from everywhere and your eye averages it. In a shot there is one light, one angle, one moment. What the camera records is not the card's colour but the shape of the light across it, which is why two cards that look similar on a desk can land completely differently on screen.
Three rules follow, and they cover most of the subject:
- A surface that spreads light reads as an object.
- A surface that reflects light reads as a mirror, and shows your room.
- A surface with no variation at all reads as a drawing.
Finish by finish
| Finish | On camera | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| Black metal | The most legible. The light across it is the whole image. | Nothing bright in front of it. |
| Titanium | Holds detail where black goes to nothing. | Forgiving. Works in most light. |
| Brushed gold | Reads as expensive instantly. | Light crossing the grain, not straight on. |
| Matte carbon | Survives bad light better than anything. | Almost nothing. |
| Frosted glass | Reads as modern, and the frosting is itself a gradient. | Any soft source. |
| Holographic | Alive in motion, flat and pastel when still. | Movement during the take. |
| Pearl | Subtle to the point of invisible on a small screen. | A close shot and a moving angle. |
| Rose gold | Warm and distinct, turns grey under cold light. | A warm key light. |
The stack changes the answer
A wallet does not show one card, it shows a stack: four or five strips of colour with one full card in front. For every card but the front one, the only visible part is a band a few millimetres tall, and a band has no surface to speak of. Which means:
- Pick the finish of the front card for the light you have. It is the only one whose surface will be read.
- Pick the rest for contrast. Three dark bands in a row merge into one object. Alternate light and dark and the stack reads as a stack.
What the app does with this
Every finish in Larp Cards is drawn by the app, live, from the finish you pick and the text you type: an issuer name, a cardholder, four digits. The practical consequence on a shoot is that the finish is a decision you can change between two takes rather than a file you have to re commission. Five of the twenty-two are in the free version, which is enough to find out which one your light likes.
The network mark on the card is the real one. The card around it is our own art, and copying a bank's own card, name or logo is not available here and not allowed. Why that line sits where it does.
A test that takes two minutes
Put the phone where it will be in the shot, under the light it will have, and flick through four finishes while watching the camera's screen rather than the phone's. The one that still looks like an object when you stop paying attention is the one to use. This is faster and more reliable than any rule, including the ones above.
Questions
Which card finish looks best on camera?
Matte and brushed finishes, because the light falling across them is the image. Black metal is the most legible of all, as long as nothing bright is in front of it.
Why does my holographic card look grey on video?
Because the effect is an angle shift, and a static shot gives it one angle. Tilt the card during the take and it returns; hold it still and there is nothing for the effect to do.
Do glossy cards film badly?
They film the room. The darker the card, the more it mirrors, which is why a high gloss black card so often shows a ceiling light instead of a card.
Does the finish matter more than the colour?
On camera, yes, and it is not close. Two cards of the same colour in different finishes read as different objects; two colours in the same finish read as the same object painted twice.
The wallet for your next scene, filled in before the coffee
A stack of cards you drew yourself, with balances, purchases and a contactless payment that plays out on screen. It holds no real card and pays nothing.
- Cards without a number limit in the stack
- All twenty-two finishes, black metal to frosted glass
- A page for every purchase: amount, merchant, status, card
- On your home screen, full size, with no browser bar
Cancel anytime · Secure payment by Stripe · Open the card studio
Keep reading
- Guide: Designing a card that reads on cameraWhy half the finishes that look best on a desk disappear through a lens, and what to type on the card.
- Why a fake wallet screenshot stops working on cameraA screenshot survives a scroll on a feed and dies the moment a camera watches it. The four moments that give one away, and…
- Saying a video is staged, without killing the jokeThree different duties get rolled into one word, disclosure, and only one of them is about staging. Which is which, and five…
- Four reasons a screen recording reads as a screen recordingA capture is mechanically different from a filmed shot in four ways, and all four survive colour grading. Which is why the…